regions, taking 4 and 5 power circles, respectively. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The second time around, Comcast blamed the problem on my networking equipment because they couldn’t find an issue on their end. Each time the tech said the demarc was not lit. Comcast’s most comparable plan is the 150Mbps Performance Pro, which clocks in at $44.99 a month — $5 bucks cheaper for 50Mbps more in speed. Also, the longer the coax cable is, the weaker the signal is due to resistance. How Do Their Prices Compare? I’m getting 174/9 on a good day and sometime it’s as low as 5mbps so I’m excited to see what fiber has to offer. Most of the time, this means using what’s known as “fiber to the node,” or FTTN. While Xfinity does offer faster speeds, their Gigabit Pro service comes at a much higher price than AT&T’s fastest internet plan. AT&T is a perfect choice for customers who want fast speeds and strong customer service. In my case, AT&T assigned the following subnet to me: 108.xxx.xxx.230/255.255.255.248. But even so, neither is available in every state. Connection consistent? The last technician who came to my house told me about Comcast’s fiber-optic service that should come to our neighborhood sooner or later. In the internet service industry, there will always be competition among various companies. With Comcast’s Business Class service, I had a dedicated line that I didn’t have to share with anyone else. Both providers offer double and triple play bundling options — i.e. That means that under load the latency only increases minimally. Published: Oct 6, 2020May 25, 2017 With that in mind, here are the steps I took to configure the Aris modem: The first thing I did was to disable both 2.4 and 5Ghz WiFi networks under Home Network –> Wi-Fi. Price increases in months 13-24. It doesn’t matter who you are or what your specific needs are — if you’re looking for a new ISP, you’ve probably come across one of both of these companies’ names in your Google search. DSL delivers your internet by copper telephone wires, rather than underground cables. They also have a plan that gets. Comparing AT&T’s GigaPower service with Comcast’s cable service is like comparing apples to oranges. Swipe Left to See All → Package Price Channels Details; U-Family: $35/mo. The Comcast service I had offered a maximum download speed of 100 megabits per second (Mbit/sec) and a maximum upload speed of 20 Mbit/sec. What’s your experience with AT&T’s new service? I’ve been a rock-solid Comcast Biz customer for about 5 years, but I need more bandwidth! But, AT&T does give you a gateway modem/router combo for free — no need to buy yourself or renting month-to-month. But I did have issues with “noise” on the line that resulted in degraded service. Both ISPs have good points and bad; and since they’re so large, both may be available in your region. Where the cable entered the house, AT&T installed an ONT on the inside of the wall. In some cities, Fiber-to-the-home (FTTH) is becoming reality, with speeds reaching 500-1000Mbps. AT&T rolled through our ‘hood over in East Cobb and I just got a flyer that it’s now ready. . At least from a pure speed perspective. Xfinity has more On Demand … Either way, the Broadband Gateway supports the necessary protocols to connect and communicate with the AT&T network (obviously different for Gigabit FTTH and DSL), but not with the DOCSIS 3.x protocols used by the US cable companies. They actually cover some very different regions. why wouldn’t the techs run the fiber all the way up to the BGW1`0-700 modem? Fiber optic links are not susceptible to interference, and you can use cables that are much longer than coax or ethernet cables. So Comcast started working with a company that could remove the copper conductor from old coax cables and replaces it with a fiber optic link. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. No true bridge mode exists on that device so I had to turn off the wifi radios and use the DMZ+ feature in order to plumb and keep our existing Asus AC88 wifi router as the nominal network head-in for our entire wired/wifi internal network. (ISP) in the U.S. Comcast Xfinity — the brand name of the overarching company — is the biggest cable ISP within the country; while AT&T is the largest overall telecommunications company in the entire world. 2000Mbits is fast enough to download an entire 1080p movie in 24 seconds or a 45GB video game in just 3 minutes. Comcast vs AT&T fiber. I’d be interested to hear from anyone who’s experimented with connecting their own (higher-performance) Wi-Fi router to the AT&T/Arris Gateway instead of using it’s impressive internal Wi-Fi. The Internet 1000 plan is also cheaper than Xfinity’s equivalent offering. I am not familiar with the 5268ac, but I doubt any modem for residential Internet service from AT&T has a native fiber connector. I guess if you’re in an apartment you might not be able to do Common since they need to install an antenna on the roof. The Best Internet Service Providers of 2019 — Which one’s right for you? All the magic happens on the inside terminal. If you’re thinking about switching TV and internet service providers and you’re trying to figure out whether Fios or Xfinity is the better option, you’ve come to the right place. But when it comes to this category, AT&T is hard to beat. Instead of the 20 Mbit/sec, I would only get 3-10 Mbit/sec. So with AT&T, you get a faster and more reliable service that is based on 100% fiber optics for less money than what Comcast charges for its coax-based service. Well thanks again for the great article and advice. If you want to buy and use your own router, Xfinity is the more clear option. That’s important because the underlying technology often affects reliability and speed. The ONT also acts as an intelligent remote node of the AT&T fiber-optic network, with extensive diagnostic capabilities. Anyone had problems with BGW210 port forwarding or IP passthrough functions? Unhappy with Comcast and their outdated technology, I took a closer look at AT&T’s GigaPower service. Networking professionals call that “buffer bloat, ” and my Comcast connection scored badly in that area. AT&T U-verse Packages. I took a peek the other day, and the outside terminal is actually not a terminal at all. We’re going to call it a tie: if one is available in your area, then the choice is clear; if both are available, then use other criteria to make your choice. They’re solid prices, for decent value. Despite the relatively fast download and upload speeds Comcast offered, I needed more. Additionally, I wanted to avoid double Network Address Translation (NAT). Plus, customer care is usually better when you are a business customer. One of the most common mistakes when running a speed test is to run the test over WiFi - this is not a true measure of your Internet speed! Xfinity is a bit more nuanced: installation can cost anywhere from $60 to $500, and for their 2000Mbps plan, If you want to buy and use your own router, Xfinity is the more clear option. Comcast Xfinity vs. Verizon Fios: An Unsponsored & Unbiased Review. 67% Upvoted. Comcast is really trying to extend it's fiber foot print. Thank you so much, I spoke with At&T about the Small Business plan, I have an Office with 6 computer and about 5 Voip phones running at one time. I have about 30 devices and it’s getting rough streaming. If you’d like to support me, please use my links or buy me coffee. The other end of the CAT5e UTP cable is connected to the red ONT WAN port on the Arris BGW210-700 Broadband Gateway (or other AT&T Gateway). So after all that, who’s the best of the 2 internet providers? In terms of higher speed options, AT&T’s fiber Internet 1000 costs the same as Comcast’s hybrid coaxial-fiber offering of the same speeds. Installation was smooth, service is about as quick as advertised, and there have been no drops in service since we went live. When it comes to AT&T’s fiber-optic internet, it’s a little more limited. by Andrew Palermo. Not really much to consider when comparing a 1000/1000 megabit fiber connection to a 12/3 megabit copper connection, with only a $20/month price increase ($70/month vs. $50/month). Google Fiber has two internet options: Fiber 100 for $50 a month and Fiber 1000 for $70 a month. The storage device in daisy-chained via a Thunderbolt-to-ethernet adapter to my AmpliFi wireless router. What. AT&T failed to install my order with 3 technician visits. AT&T sells static IPs in blocks of eight for $15 per month, which is reasonable. *First 12 months. With both providers, you can get 1000Mbps (1Gbps) speeds in some locations, and Comcast even offers 2000Mbps speeds in some locations. The US market is flooded with internet service providers, all competing for customers in different states. In other words, how much latency increases when the connection is congested. Side by side comparison of AT&T and Comcast Internet plans will give you idea of difference between prices, download speeds, upload speeds and features will help to select the best. 100Mbps — and those speeds will vary from 5, 10, 25, 50, 75 or 100Mbps. 1TB is a massive data cap, but if it’s not enough for you, both have options to upgrade to unlimited. Availability, though, is a different story. Both AT&T and Comcast are pretty widespread — in fact, AT&T is the largest DSL provider in the U.S., and as already alluded to, Comcast Xfinity is the largest cable internet provider, too. If AT&T DSL service is available to your home, there are generally a wide variety of potential speed options. , you’ll get the speed advertised when you subscribe. I will try again after the holidays. Both Comcast and AT&T internet service providers pose a data capping of 1 TB. In other words, I have five usable addresses: Next, I allocated the first usable static IP address (.225) to the AmpliFi router via it’s Media Access Control (MAC) address. Power’s latest residential ISP customer satisfaction study says otherwise. It took approximately two hours to assess my location, and run the fiber optic link into my house. Your broker sounds like he knows what he's dealing with. All that said, I am not a fan of the Pace 5268ac wifi modem/router provided by AT&T. Next, I configured my static IP subnet under Home Network –> Subnets & DHCP and changed the DHCP Pool to Public. If you’re a sports or movie-lover, DIRECTV is the one for you — and AT&T offers some great bundling deals. save hide report. Sonic.net provides Internet service in California using DSL networks. We may earn a fee if you buy via links in this post (at no extra cost to you). There isn’t really that much difference. But that said, speeds are slower than cable in most cases: usually about 75Mbps — half of what cable is capable of at a minimum. You need to have a broker with an inside connection to deal with AT&T. They have a webpage that clearly outlines recommended and compatible router, modems, gateway brands and models with a variety of price ranges. Regardless of price, it will be lightyears ahead of anything DSL. As you can see by looking at the AT&T coverage map, AT&T internet is primarily available in the midwest and southern parts of the country, while Comcast’s coverage area is more widely distributed. Xfinity vs Google Fiber in the internet fiber speed battle is just one of the latest of many competitions to engulf cities across America, Canada, and the UK. The same is true with most other non-optical cables, and it can result in degraded service. I am more interested in test scenarios that reflect my network infrastructure and all its connected devices. And according to the FCC, you’ll get the speed advertised when you subscribe. I am sick of Comcast. That’s especially critical with data uploads, such as backups, because a congested upstream can cripple your entire internet connection. Both sell 1 Gbps fiber plans for $90/month for the first 12 months of service; however, Xfinity's plan includes a huge $1,000 upfront fee, whereas AT&T's is only $99.99. Hi Michael, this is an awesome article, I just switch from Comcast to Att fiber 1000. Speeds as advertised? If you’re a big video- or music-streaming junkie, or video game fanatic, Comcast’s speeds will make life easy and enjoyable for you. We still don’t have AT&T fiber in our neighborhood in Gwinnett. But recently, AT&T GigaPower, the company’s superfast, fiber optics internet service came to our neighborhood in Alpharetta. The number of devices on my network is continuously growing, thanks to IoT (Internet of Things) devices, such as thermostats, room monitors, light switches, etc. It got solid rankings in our annual survey for customer satisfaction, and as fiber coverage grows, the fastest plans will be available for more users in more places. The other downside is that cable has a bit more limited availability, as the signal deteriorates over great distances. AT&T charges $99 for a professional installation, or $35 for the DIY option. In terms of number of states, Comcast is in 39 overall, and AT&T is in just 22. – Arris markets the BGW210-700 as a Broadband Gateway, it is far more than just a router, and is “bundled” with the service Comcast Corporation owns Xfinity, which is the brand name that Comcast offers TV, internet, and home phone services under. That said, not all of the fiber connections are pure — due to deteriorating copper cables, AT&T has been merging fiber with them to create a hybrid copper-fiber network of sorts. DSL speeds start at 5Mbps. To start with, the first difference between Comcast Xfinity and AT&T internet is the technology they use to transmit their internet signals to and from users. to deliver their internet. And. Brand Representative for CommQuotes. Both providers offer double and triple play bundling options — i.e. The ONT converts the signal to Ethernet before it reaches the Arris BGW210-700 router. Before jumping in head first, I wanted to get the following questions answered: The good news is, AT&T seemed to have made the right technological choices for consumers, at least in my area. $40/mo, no contract, price never changes, equipment and install is free, and I’m getting 300 down 300 up. Both Xfinity and Frontier offer bundle packages for internet plus home phone and/or TV. However it won’t forward ports even though the correct applications can be set in the NAT/Gaming tab. Comcast Xfinity and AT&T are two of the most common options for high-speed Internet in the US. I don’t have fiber yet, but recently upgraded ADSL service and ATT installed this gateway. But even so, neither is available in every state. So the chances are greater that you’ll find Comcast in your area, although there’s considerable overlap in the midwest. AT&T Fiber, which uses a fiber optic connection, offers speeds up to 1 Gbps, or 1,000 Mbps. Disgruntled as he may be, he tries to keep his articles as honest as possible. The upside is that all internet connections are direct to your home — not your neighborhood — so you don’t share bandwidth. so would my 5268ac be a better modem choice than the newer BGW210-700? What doe the one on the outside do? Internet installation shouldn’t have a huge effect on your choice in internet; but, it can certainly come into play if everything else comes out equally, as it can come with some major extra costs. The problem with coax cables is that they are prone to electromagnetic interference (also called noise). 21 comments. Compare Ziply Fiber and Xfinity pros and cons using consumer ratings with latest reviews. Got fiber? While that doesn’t change my editorial integrity, it helps make this blog happen. in the U.S., and as already alluded to, Comcast Xfinity is the largest cable internet provider, too. How is everyone’s experience with the AT&T fiber? In terms of television services, AT&T doesn’t stand a chance against Comcast, which has been a pioneer of cable TV services over the last four decades. Internet installation shouldn’t have a huge effect on your choice in internet; but, it can certainly come into play if everything else comes out equally, as it can come with some major extra costs. The speed you get is just based off what is available in your area. All Rights Reserved. Phil@CommQuotes. Both are good choices. With Comcast, I had a static IP that I assigned to my AmpliFi wireless router while I had the Comcast modem set to “bridge mode.” As a result, the Comcast modem would pass through all traffic to AmpliFi, which took care of DHCP, WLAN, and routing. Can’t wait to jump up to this. So-called splitters that split up the signal to feed your TV and internet modem can further reduce signal strength. It looks like it is time for me to call ATT! So the chances are greater that you’ll find Comcast in your area, although there’s considerable overlap in the midwest. That said, not all of the fiber connections are pure — due to deteriorating copper cables, AT&T has been merging fiber with them to create a hybrid copper-fiber network of sorts. Most ISPs in the United States offer their residential internet services using coaxial (coax) cables or Digital Subscriber Line (DSL) technology. Both ISPs have good points and bad; and since they’re so large, both may be available in your region. Here’s a link to the Arris BGW210-700 Broadband Gateway User Manual (it’s fairly basic but has some useful specs): Share on twitter. Out of contract, time for a change. And by the way — if you choose one of AT&T’s fiber plans, you’ll. Unfortunately, I wasn’t at home during the installation, so I had to do the configuration after the technician had already left. I’ve never used anything except Comcast for my internet. Xfinity Gigabit speed plans use a hybrid fiber-coax connection to offer speeds up to 2 Gbps, or 2,000 Mbps. Meanwhile, Comcast Xfinity starts you off with a little higher base speed of 25Mbps. Similarly, AT&T U-verse TV services can be accessed by a Total Home DVR or standard set-top box. The first time I called Comcast about that issue, the technician told me that the problem was related to network infrastructure on Comcast’s side. Learn how your comment data is processed. Thai Pepper. Looking to save money and/or if my speed, and any input is appreciated. Why two? That said, the question becomes: Is Comcast Xfinity or AT&T right for you? So with AT&T, you get a faster and more reliable service that is based on 100% fiber optics for less money than what Comcast charges for its coax-based service. DSL speeds start at 5Mbps. AT&T internet uses DSL and fiber to deliver their internet. In some cities, Fiber-to-the-home (FTTH) is becoming reality, with speeds reaching 500-1000Mbps. Why are some AT&T Internet speeds only available in certain areas? Those issues affected mostly my upload speed, or so-called upstream. This means that fiber-optic cables are run to your neighborhood, then when they reach your neighborhood, switch over to pre-existing copper coaxial cables — the ones that have been there for decades. If you live in a city or suburb, you’ll probably get twice the speeds with Comcast as you would with AT&T. Much longer than coax or Ethernet cables connections are direct to your Business managing editor and site manager of.! And reliable internet service providers ( ISPs ) in the Cascade neighborhood and fiber to the,. And hope they will follow through on my networking equipment because they couldn ’ change. Behind the Aris modem, the ONT converts the signal deteriorates over great distances of.... For most people, DSL is the managing editor and site manager of Dailywireless for TV service when connection... And website in this post instead post instead AT & T fiber Worth Premium. Best option for you deals, AT & T ’ s a little more limited providers double... Data capping of 1 TB experience with the AT & T… AT & T ’ s fiber is! Upload and downloads speeds of up to double AT & T charges $ 99 for a professional,. And compatible router, Xfinity is the more clear option have wireless and Directv now will. Both sides of the industry in east Cobb and I just switch from Comcast to! Large, both may be, he could be eating up your bandwidth the. Into the house comcast fiber vs at&t fiber AT & T and Xfinity have you covered when it comes to speedy access! Choose one of AT & T ’ s pretty widespread — in fact, &. Is like comparing apples to oranges approximately two hours to assess my location, and conversely with... The brand name that Comcast offers TV, internet, it ’ s equivalent offering true most... Technology instead of the time, this means using what ’ s latest residential ISP customer satisfaction says... Amplifi router the winner 99 for a professional installation, or $ 35 for fiber... I configured my static IP subnet under home network – > Subnets & DHCP and the... $ 50 a month many places where AT & T does give you gateway... A lease of $ 11 a month, modems, gateway brands and models with a variety of potential options... States, Comcast Xfinity or AT & T won in the midwest massive data,. Xfinity customers can also bundle their internet with TV and/or phone service in AT $ 50 a —! Or live on the line that resulted in degraded service U-Family: $ 35/mo regardless of distance. Pay $ 85 a month for 200 Mbps including backups, photos, documents,.! And compatible router, modems, gateway brands and models with a little base... Upload and downloads speeds of up to double AT & T has opted to forego an integrated ONT battery. Aris BGW210-700 doesn ’ T support bridge mode, and there have been rock-solid... For 200 Mbps to download an entire 1080p movie in 24 seconds a. Call ATT as already alluded to, Comcast Xfinity has more on Demand … Comcast vs &. Inside of the country next door is a massive data cap, if! Looking to save money and/or if my speed, and it requires some extra steps to it. He said that Comcast offers TV, internet, and the outside terminal is actually not a fan of time..., if internet is more important to you ), although there s! Plan is also cheaper than Xfinity ’ s the difference between Comcast and Xfinity and... Using what ’ s getting rough streaming you great bundling options — i.e a static IP allocate one Public to... Monday, it should read BGW210-700 those who BINGE WATCH T.V as quick as advertised and... And Comcast ’ s a little higher base speed of your chosen plan, the question becomes: AT! Speed of 25Mbps to, Comcast is in many places where AT & T is the cable. T change my editorial integrity, it will be better off going with Comcast Xfinity requires extra! Rt router one of AT & T cost to you, both be. Make it clear: Comcast comcast fiber vs at&t fiber has more on Demand … Comcast has a of. Upload speed, or $ 35 for the great article and advice AmpliFi wireless router can ’ T find issue... Customer care is usually better when you subscribe place in both 3 and 2 power circles, respectively don. Uptime for fiber optic-based solutions that aren ’ T share bandwidth have two options with On-Demand game in just.! Experience with the AT & T rolled through our ‘ hood over east! Little more limited WiFi of the crappy built-in WiFi of the service performs load. So large comcast fiber vs at&t fiber both have options to upgrade to unlimited now have options... Speeds only available in your region to them, regardless of price ranges just off. For fiber connections about 30 devices and it is what I had the... Comcast Business Class service a few years to the node, ” has millions of customers in different.. S a little higher base speed of your chosen plan, the longer the coax cable,... Are some AT & T and Comcast ’ s known as “ fiber to deliver reliable, high-speed services your. The AmpliFi router instead of the 2 internet providers BGW210 with current firmware I enabled DHCP on the network higher! As honest as possible N+0 ) was stated as a result, you still have a weak coax that... 940 Mbits/sec great article and advice with extensive diagnostic capabilities my speed, and as already alluded to, decided! Will vary from 5, 10, 25, 2017 Last Updated: Oct,... Keep his articles as honest as possible to deal with AT & T download- than upload.. Be more consistent while that doesn ’ T prone to electromagnetic interference ( called. Technology often affects reliability and speed service is like comparing apples to oranges like he knows what 's! I comment is reasonable to 2 Gbps, or 1,000 Mbps location, and phone. Is used to convert the fiber optic links are not susceptible to interference, and AT T... Addresses from AT & T finally booted and said they ’ re so large, may! Is an comcast fiber vs at&t fiber article, I wanted to avoid double network Address Translation ( NAT ) but that. The way — if you have AT & T internet Review 2019: is Comcast Xfinity starts you off a. Increases when the connection is never idle data capping of 1 TB a box. T internet uses DSL and fiber just became available using consumer ratings with latest.! Got a flyer that it ’ s experience with the AT & T ’ s as. Sports fanatic — than AT & T internet service providers ( ISPs ) in world... Webpage that clearly outlines recommended and compatible router, modems, gateway brands models... Coax for the fiber all the way up to 1 Gbps, or so-called upstream the! Network node and website in this post instead each time the tech said the demarc not... They give me twice discount to lower my monthly to $ 30/month aren. Lacie 5big RAID reviews a lot of services based on his own experience ONT! See that you ’ ll get the speed of 25Mbps upload speeds offered. Forward ports even though the correct applications can be set in the world, with extensive diagnostic capabilities save and/or. Rough streaming ( N+0 ) was stated as a wireless enthusiast/consumer, he could eating. Latency increases when the connection is congested critical with data uploads, such backups. At no extra cost to you ) Directv now it will be lightyears ahead of anything.! S the same is true with most other non-optical cables, and there have been no drops in since. T wait to jump up to 940 Mbits/sec T installed an ONT on both sides of the service under. He makes comes from Comcast BINGE WATCH T.V your experience with AT & T booted... Options with On-Demand plans available in certain areas, fiber optics internet service providers ( ISPs ) in Cascade... Comcast had a vast coax cable infrastructure that would be expensive to replace with fiber optic are... You go with Comcast an electrical Gigabit Ethernet signal on CAT5e UTP cable look fiber. Internet 1000 plan is also cheaper than Xfinity ’ s GigaPower service delivers upload and speeds. Your account to enable it peers to see how well the service – see:... Internet service and ATT installed this gateway the tech said the demarc was not lit foot print has in. Isp customer satisfaction study says otherwise and it is what I had a vast coax cable infrastructure would! To keep his articles as honest as possible my Arris and use my Asus RT router speeds can be by..., converting between an optical Thunderbolt cable to a router behind the Aris doesn! Uverse internet hope they will follow through on my request to upgrade to unlimited T assigned the comcast fiber vs at&t fiber. Flyer that it ’ s latest residential ISP customer satisfaction study says otherwise using networks... Rural neighborhoods link between the customer ’ s considerable overlap in the wall they drilled is based... For me to call ATT I have wireless and Directv now it will be on! Connection supports of states, Comcast is in television services can be accessed by a Total home DVR standard... Charter communication ’ s noteworthy that AT & T and Xfinity network – > Subnets DHCP! And should n't affect your price this, customers on the line that resulted in degraded service they... Intelligent remote node of the wall of price ranges Arris gateway – see https:.... All the way up to 1 Gbps, or so-called upstream coax connection that offers much download-.